REAL Health Providers Act Proposed Rule: 90-Day Verification, Letter Grades, and Cost-Sharing Protections
On October 16, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) released its proposed rule implementing the REAL Health Providers Act. In July, we covered what the law means for Medicare Advantage provider directories. The proposal fills in several details health plans have been waiting for, including how CMS would grade directory accuracy, how behavioral health providers would be represented in the annual sample, and how plans would apply cost-sharing protections when members rely on inaccurate listings. Most requirements would begin in contract year (CY) 2028, with public scores following in CY 2029.
Most provider listings would need verification every 90 days
Beginning in CY 2028, network-based MA plans (and private fee-for-service plans that rely on a provider network) would verify provider directory information at least every 90 days. Only acute inpatient hospitals, intensive care units, and surgical services would move to a 12-month cycle; inpatient psychiatric, outpatient behavioral health, skilled nursing, and other providers would stay on the 90-day cycle. If a plan cannot verify a provider’s information during the applicable cycle, the directory would need to flag the listing as potentially out of date. Once a plan determines that a provider no longer participates in its network, it would have five business days to remove the provider from both its online directory and its posted printable version. Existing rules requiring plans to update listings within 30 days of receiving new information would continue to apply.
Verification methods will matter as much as frequency. A national registry can help confirm a provider’s identity, for example, but it may have little to say about whether the provider is accepting new patients. Plans will need to identify which sources can verify each required field and how to resolve conflicting information before it reaches members.
Public grades would give network participation the most weight
CMS proposes that plans conduct an annual directory accuracy analysis beginning in CY 2028 and report a score for each applicable plan. The proposed methodology would translate a weighted score into a letter grade, from A (90% or higher) to F (49% or lower). Network participation would account for 40% of the score, contact information for 20%, and primary practice or facility addresses for another 20%. The remaining 20% covers specialty, accessibility accommodations, telehealth capabilities, and whether the provider is accepting new patients. Beginning in CY 2029, plans would display their scores in their directories, and CMS would publish the scores in a machine-readable file.
CMS also proposes that mental health and substance use disorder treatment providers make up 35% of the annual sample. The sample share determines which providers get reviewed. The scoring weights are separate and determine how much each field counts. Plans that track accuracy only across the full network should break out behavioral health results separately. An overall accuracy rate can mask disconnected phone numbers, incorrect locations, or outdated participation status in a network members already have difficulty navigating.
An inaccurate listing could change what a member pays
Starting in CY 2028, the proposal would protect members who receive otherwise covered care from an out-of-network provider listed as in-network in the plan’s online directory on the date they made the appointment. Eligible members would pay the lower of the in-network amount or the amount that would otherwise apply, and that amount would count toward the in-network maximum out-of-pocket limit. Plans would be expected to apply the protection whenever they know or reasonably should know it applies, not only when a member asks. To do that, they would need to establish when the appointment was booked and reconstruct what the directory showed that day. If a plan can’t document either in time, the protection would default in the member’s favor. CMS proposes requiring plans to keep daily directory archives for at least 10 years.
What plans can assess now
- Test the five-day removal workflow. Trace a recent provider termination from the date the plan determined the provider had left the network through removal from the online and printable directories. Check where a handoff or publishing schedule could delay the update.
- Run a baseline accuracy review. Use the proposed sampling approach to see how behavioral health records perform. Start with participation status, phone numbers, and practice locations, which together account for 80% of the proposed score.
- Walk through a cost-sharing request. Ask whether the plan could retrieve the directory as it appeared on a specific date, confirm when the member booked the appointment, and route the request for a determination. That exercise can surface gaps across provider contracting, directory operations, and member services.
Comments on the proposed rule are due December 15, 2026, at 5 PM ET. For all the details, Read the full proposed rule here.
.jpg)

